In Florida DUI cases, a plea bargain (or plea deal) is an agreement between the defendant and the prosecution where the defendant agrees to plead guilty or no contest to a lesser charge or receive reduced penalties in exchange for certain concessions. Plea bargains can be beneficial for both parties: they offer the defendant a chance to avoid the uncertainties of a trial and potentially severe penalties, while the prosecution secures a conviction without the need for a trial.

​

Types of Plea Bargains in Florida DUI Cases

​

1. Reduction of Charges:

Less Severe Charges: The defendant might plead guilty or no contest to a lesser offense, such as reckless driving, in exchange for the prosecution dropping the DUI charge. Reckless driving generally carries less severe penalties than a DUI.

Non-DUI Offense: In some cases, the charge might be reduced to a non-DUI offense that does not carry the same legal consequences as a DUI conviction.

​

2. Reduced Penalties:

Fines and Jail Time: The defendant may receive a reduction in fines, jail time, or both. For example, if the standard penalty includes jail time, the plea deal might involve a shorter jail sentence or alternative sentencing options like house arrest or community service.

Probation Terms: The terms of probation might be less restrictive in a plea bargain compared to the standard terms for a DUI conviction.

​

3. Alternative Sentencing:

DUI School: The plea deal may involve attending a DUI education program or other rehabilitative programs instead of harsher penalties.

Community Service: The defendant might be required to complete community service hours as part of the plea deal instead of facing jail time.

​

4. Dismissal of Certain Charges:

Dismissal of Aggravating Factors: If there are multiple charges or aggravating factors (like a high BAC or a prior DUI), the plea deal might involve dropping some of these charges or reducing their severity.

​

Factors Influencing a Plea Bargain

​

1. Strength of the Evidence:

Evidence Review: The prosecution will consider the strength of the evidence against the defendant when offering a plea bargain. If the evidence is strong and likely to result in a conviction, the plea deal might be more favorable to the defendant.

​

2. Prior Record:

Criminal History: The defendant's prior criminal record, especially related to DUI offenses, can influence the plea bargain. A first-time offender might receive a better deal compared to someone with a history of DUI convictions.

​

3. Circumstances of the Arrest:

Arrest Details: Factors such as the circumstances of the arrest, any aggravating factors (e.g., accidents, injuries, high BAC), and the defendant’s behavior during the arrest can impact the plea negotiations.

​

4. Negotiation Strategy:

Defense Strategy: The defense attorney’s skill in negotiating and presenting mitigating factors can influence the plea bargain’s terms. An experienced DUI attorney will negotiate for the best possible outcome for the defendant.

 

Pros and Cons of Plea Bargains

​

Pros:

Certainty: A plea bargain offers a certain outcome, avoiding the unpredictability of a trial.

Reduced Penalties: Defendants might receive lighter penalties than those that could result from a conviction at trial.

Avoiding a Criminal Record: In some cases, pleading to a lesser charge may avoid a DUI conviction on the record.

​

Cons:

Admission: Accepting a plea deal generally involves admitting guilt or no contest, which can have implications for the defendant’s record and future.

Limited Appeal: Once a plea deal is accepted, the ability to appeal the conviction is usually limited.

​

Steps to Take

​

1. Consult with an Attorney:

Legal Advice: Our law firm can advise you on whether a plea bargain is in your best interest and negotiate the best possible deal.

​

2. Understand the Deal:

Plea Details: Ensure you fully understand the terms of the plea bargain, including any potential impacts on your criminal record, driving privileges, and future legal obligations.

​

3. Make an Informed Decision:

Decision-Making: Make an informed decision based on the advice of your attorney, the evidence against you, and the potential outcomes of going to trial.

​

Conclusion

​

Plea bargains in Florida DUI cases offer a way to potentially reduce charges or penalties in exchange for a guilty or no contest plea. The terms of a plea bargain can vary based on the specifics of the case, including the strength of the evidence, the defendant’s prior record, and the circumstances of the arrest. We can help you navigate the plea bargaining process and to ensure that any plea deal is fair and in your best interest.